Is Pluto a planet?

Is Pluto a planet?

16 answers , last was 15 years ago

Whats the official word?

Asked by GeeBee Khalique in Astronomy at 9:07pm on February 28th, 2008
Justin Mckay 1317
Answered at 2:04pm on February 15th, 2009
not any more. it is considered to be a planetoid (because of it's size) even though it has a satellite.
Joyce McCarthy 1416
Answered at 2:30am on February 7th, 2009
I suppose it depends on who you ask. Many books still say it is a planet. Postcards at gift shops say it is a planet. However, like many of the great minds here on this site and abroad, it is a dwarf plant.... currently.
Alex Cly New Brain
Answered at 12:44am on March 19th, 2008
All pluto is known as is an icy body, due to the fact that we have been discovering more icy bodies close to our solar system, so that means that it would be brought into question whether or not to classify them as planets a well so it is easier if it is just called an icy body. Also the term planet should be applied to things with special characteristics
Brandon Hillard 1236
Answered at 10:45pm on March 9th, 2008
I believe Pluto recently was reclassified as a Pluton along with two or three other bodies that were once considered planets. I think, meaning I'm not quite sure but to be a planet one of the requirements is that you must have an atmosphere and Pluto doesn't because it lacks the gravitation pull to keep an atmosphere.
David Henderson 1224
Answered at 1:43pm on March 4th, 2008
There are three types of "planet" in our star system:

1) Terrestrial planets. These include Mercury, Venus, Earth, and Mars.
2) Gas giants. These include Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus, and Neptune.
3) Dwarf planets. These include Pluto, Ceres, and Eris.

It should be noted that "dwarf" does not mean "not"; thus, a "dwarf planet" is a "planet", according to basic English rules of grammar. Where scientific jargon and English grammar disagree, I go with English.

So currently, our star system has eleven recognized planets.

davidh
Bryan Lamb 1024
Answered at 8:29pm on March 2nd, 2008
Pluto was discovered in 1930 by Clyde Tombaugh. A ninth planet was being sought due to believed discrepancies between the Newtonian-predicted orbit of Neptune (discovered in 1846) and its actual orbit. this was exactly how Neptune was discovered, by analyzing differences between the observed orbit of Uranus (discovered 1781) and its predicted orbit.

however, Pluto's discovery was mostly due to a "mistake". When Neptune was discovered, its mass was estimated, but actually incorrectly, which affected the equations used to predict its path. as a result the discrepancy that came about between observed and predicted was due to this error, and thus an error led to the search for a ninth planet. When Pluto was discovered it was realized that it was far too small to have caused a gravitational effect on Neptune of the magnitude previously believed, and then the error with Neptune's mass was realized.

in 1978, Pluto's largest moon, Charon, was discovered. not long after its discovery, Pluto and charon;s orbital plane coincided with the earth's own orbital plane, allowing us to see Pluto and charon eclipse each other numerous times. this enabled us to learn more things about the two objects. Pluto and Charon have the closest relative size of any object and its moon (Earth and its moon is next). our moon is tidally locked to the Earth (keeps the same face to us all the time, as anyone who has ever looked at the moon can attest to). what is less well known is that this is also true of jupiter's four largest moons (Ganymede, Io, Callisto and Europa) . The same is also true of Charon relative to Pluto, BUT INTERESTINGLY ALSO OF PLUTO RELATIVE TO CHARON. put another way, Both Pluto and charon keep the same face towards each other the whole time. this has happened because of the similar relative size. Charon's gravitational tides effect on Pluto is large enough to slow down Pluto's rotation rate. Our moon is doing the same to the Earth, but at a much slower rate.

the fact that Pluto and Charon are tidally locked and more similar in size than other Planet - moon systems suggests (in addition to the numerous other unusual facts about Pluto -- its highly eccentric orbit, its small size, etc suggests that perhaps it is not really supposed to be a planet. however, a planet it remained until in 2003, something big happened.

The event that eventually led to Pluto being "declassified" as a planet was the discovery of Eris in 2003. Eris is the furthest known object in the solar system. Its size is slightly larger than Pluto. it would be difficult to continue to call Pluto a planet and not to call something bigger than Pluto a planet, so the choice was either call Pluto something else or have a bunch of other things we call planets also.

The Kuiper belt is basically a region in the solar system approximately beyond Neptune to a fair bit further out. Pluto is now considered to be a member of the kuiper belt, the first such object that was discovered. nowadays, there are numerous kuiper belt objects known.

One specific type of kuiper belt object are "Plutons" which are basically objects which are like pluto. one of the key characteristics of plutons is that they have a 3:2 orbital resonance with Neptune (i.e. that they go twice around the sun for every three times Neptune does.) These objects supposedly gradually migrated into such an orbit by regular "tugs" by Neptune, similar to how Jupiter affects a large number of asteroids in the asteroid belt between Mars and Juipter.

Before the discovery of Eris, there wasn't really a formal definition of what a "planet" is. because of the discovery of other objects like Pluto, a definition needed to be created. the definition would either have to exclude Pluto as a planet, or include Pluto and a bunch of other things.

Pluto was excluded by the clause "has not cleared its orbit" which is true because of the existence of other Plutons which orbit the sun in the same range from the sun as Pluto does.

Pluto is one of three "Dwarf Planets" in our solar system. The other two are Eris, which is larger than pluto, and Ceres, the first asteroid ever discovered in the asteroid belt (back in 1801). Ceres contains a large fraction (about 2/3) of all the mass of all the asteroids and it is one of the few which has a relatively spherical shape (which allows it to be also called a dwarf planet instead of an asteroid).

In summary, the solar system has tons of interesting things in it besides the nine (now eight) planets. look around and you can learn a lot. almost every well known object has its own unique features, and despite the fact that technically Pluto is not a planet any more does not take away from the numerous interesting things about it (including the other two moons it has, Nix and Hydra, which were discovered about 2 years ago.
Joey Clark 1976
Answered at 11:26pm on February 29th, 2008
Pluto will alway be a planet to me...I hate astronomical change!
Aaron Young 2263
Answered at 8:03pm on February 29th, 2008
Pluto is not a planet. It is a dwarf planet. It would also be fair to mention that dwarfs are people too... just that dwarf planets aren't planets.
Louis Ayensu-Mensah 1665
Answered at 5:05pm on February 29th, 2008
no, pluto is now classified as a dwarf planet because it does not clear it's own orbit. pluto is still the same pluto but after the discovery of the things in the kuiper belt, the rules were change a bit to explain what characteristics an astronomical body had to have to be classified a planet
1. It has to orbit a star: (applies because it does orbit our sun)
2. It has to clear its own orbit: (pluto does not clear its orbit but intersects with neptune and since neptune is the dominant object taking that orbit, it is classified as neptune's orbit.
3. Also, the center of gravity between pluto and its moon does not lie on the planet itself and that is another reason why pluto is not classified a planet

also, pluto is too far away and is a small rocky planet like mercury, vernus, mars, and earth but for a planet existing at that distance, it is supposed to be a big gas planet like jupiter, saturn, uranus and neptune...

So in other words, it does not fit the normal understanding of humans and since humans hate not understanding things, they either make theories about it, or if it is too off for the theories to work, they change the rules a bit
Kara Finley 1248
Answered at 1:14pm on February 29th, 2008
Everyone that has told you "no it's technically a dwarf planet" is correct. Lots of people are very attached to Pluto, but don't understand that it was demoted for a good reason. When we first found Pluto, we hadn't found the other items out in the Kuiper belt. When we found bodies in the Kuiper belt that were around the same size as Pluto (some of them were bigger!) we had to make the choice of narrowing the definition of a planet or upping the planets count in our Solar System. There had been controversy around Pluto's planet status since it was discovered, so it's understandable that it was demoted. This "demotion" doesn't make Pluto any less important, we just reclassified it, that's all. In fact, the Kuiper belt is very, very important and probably should be taught in elementary schools as well... Kuiper belt is huge.
Here's what Bill Nye has to say about it: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4pu2KLUzHbQ
=)
Load more
There are no debates yet! To start one, click "Debate this answer!" under someone's answer.
There are no debates yet! To start one, click "Debate this answer!" under someone's answer.